Fan Rage, Women & The Hobbit

Tauriel
Now that the new trailer for The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug is out and Jackson has shown a clear picture of Evangeline Lilly’s newly-created-for-the-movie elfmaid warrior Tauriel ( which I already knew about thanks to the Lego figure of her!), it seems disappointing that the majority of online reactions seems to be misogynistic and packed full of nerd-rage ( I wrote a post about this on the old Voyager blog ). While I can certainly understand the desire to stay true to the text, I can hardly see how the addition of one character to what will likely only be a relatively small section of a trilogy of 3 hour films will “destroy the joint”. Given Tolkien’s inclusion of the female warrior Eowyn in LOTR, is not the idea of a female elf warrior in keeping with his vision for Middle-Earth? The vast majority of the adaptation is extremely true to the text and the biggest plot expansion, the Necromancer in Mirkwood, is drawn from Tolkien’s other works, so I can’t help but feel that Peter Jackson & Fran Walsh’s  intentions are good, so what is people’s beef?

I think it’s fair to say that Tolkien ( and this goes for Game of Thrones and other medieval-inspired epics that have been adapted in Sansarecent years ) was trying to emulate the social norms of a fantasy version of medieval Britain- which like it or not- was not exactly female friendly. And while the lack of female characters stands as testament to this, I hardly feel like this is the most important aspect of The Hobbit and if you need to pad out the story ( as turning it into a trilogy necessitates- but that’s a whole other article ), why not pad it with some kick-ass female role-models?

This dailylife article sums it all up nicely too and brings up another victim of the fan rage – Sansa Stark from George R.R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series. Whereas Tolkien was creating a whole new genre at the time, I think that Martin is really deconstructing that genre in ASOIAF, hence his modern, and enlightened, focus on women in Westeros and beyond. Sansa is perhaps the clearest “victim” of this deconstruction, as she most clearly represents the archetype of the demur “princess just waiting around for her prince”- who is most horribly punished for her naivety.

If you’re interested in looking further, Chuck Wendig has written a great ( if naughty language heavy ) blog post about why he thinks it IS important to look at these issues in our books ( and, I suspect, by extension, our movies & TV adaptations ). What’s you take on Tauriel & Sansa? Why all the hate and rage?

5 Responses to “Fan Rage, Women & The Hobbit”

  1. Zephyr says:

    I agree completely.. I don't understand it either! Notice no one is complaining about the appearance of Legolas?

    i am told that females in any gaming situation put up with a lot of abuse too.. i do play, but have managed to avoid online gaming so far, so this isn't something i have experienced personally..

  2. Mark C says:


    Zephyr

    I agree completely.. I don't understand it either! Notice no one is complaining about the appearance of Legolas?

    i am told that females in any gaming situation put up with a lot of abuse too.. i do play, but have managed to avoid online gaming so far, so this isn't something i have experienced personally..

    I linked to this up on Facebook too and got some good reactions and even a reply blog post on Nerdalicious: http://nerdalicious.com.au/filmtv/fan-rage-women-the-hobbit-a-fans-resonse-and-some-dwarf-respect/ Olga levels her criticism at the film adaptation as a whole rather than the specifics of Tauriel or even her gender. Well worth reading! Hopefully Olga will join us here on the Forums soon.

  3. Olga says:

    Er sorry it took me so long Mark. The forum registration kept trying to defeat me (or I confused myself which is far more likely)

    I suppose people find Leogolas being included acceptable because it is technically his home and he most likely would have been there (even if Tolkien didn't make the connection later). The timeline makes sense in any case.
    I haven't read the revised manuscript of the Hobbit Tolkien began yet, but I wonder if he would have included Legolas in there to tie it in to LOTR? That was why he started the revision in any case.

  4. Mark C says:


    Olga

    Er sorry it took me so long Mark. The forum registration kept trying to defeat me (or I confused myself which is far more likely)

    I suppose people find Leogolas being included acceptable because it is technically his home and he most likely would have been there (even if Tolkien didn't make the connection later). The timeline makes sense in any case.
    I haven't read the revised manuscript of the Hobbit Tolkien began yet, but I wonder if he would have included Legolas in there to tie it in to LOTR? That was why he started the revision in any case.

    No worries- Glad you could make it on!:) I do find it interesting that Tolkien did revise The Hobbit to better align it to LOTR- something I hadn't known until a few years ago. It does make sense that Legolas would've been there and given Tolkien's interest in creating meaningful backstories and histories I wouldn't be surprised if he would've added an appearance by him, but then it would perhaps seem odd that Legolas would never mention meeting Bilbo during LOTR?

  5. Olga says:

    I haven't come across a connection between them in any of the Middle Earth histories either (although I haven't finished all of them) but I am pretty sure Tolkien hadn't created a story between them. Then again I am not sure if he created Legolas until he started writing Lord of the Rings

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Hay Day Cheats - I have some question Computer question (How long does an average person keep a computer for?
  2. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City cheats - Funny How do you get people to visit your blog and good blogging sites?
  3. Trackback - Great How do I post to my wordpress blog from my desktop, without 3rd party software?
  4. Trackback - Good info I am looking to start a blog, though I don't know which is the best way to go about …
  5. Trackback - Maybe... What makes a computer choosing random numbers, start at 3, or 5, or 3027846?
  6. Trackback - Maybe... Is it possible to hide certain blog posts on Blogger? If so, how?.. I know that I can save my …
  7. Trackback - Funny If you say admit to crimes (real or not real) on blog posts, can you be reported to the police …
  8. Trackback - wow thats great I want to use the WayBackMachine to try to retrieve my old Yahoo! 360 Blog posts, but I …
  9. Trackback - wow thats great How do I start a website that costs me nothing at all?
  10. qwxgvnmkfbrvecganfhv - Title [...]Sites of interest we've a link to[...]
  11. Trackback - I have some question The template I made doesn't have any code in it about the navbar. I'd like to bring …
  12. Trackback - I like your blog Is there a way to make your Wordpress blog posts do-follow?
  13. Trackback - I like your blog Getting a new computer. Can't seem to get my bookmarks out of firefox. Need this information TONIGHT. …
  14. Trackback - wow thats great How to make a select category on wordpress use a different domain?
  15. csevdhrbmkgnkjbhvdbjn - Title [...]The information and facts mentioned inside the write-up are some of the best readily available [...]
  16. top garcinia cambogia max - the most recent content that's being applied by nearly everybody.why is blogging important?for the average person, blogging is a cool and …
  17. Trackback - wow thats great I was diagnosed with celiac over a year ago and have started inventing my own gluten-free recipes. I've …
  18. top 5 testosterone supplements - better pr appeal. and these functions usually do not come out naturally from a person. these functions are learned through mba …
  19. Https://Www.youtube.COM/WATCH?V=-ypGoBqbtg0 - is called a "blogger".a blog can be a powerful marketing and communications tool, which helps companies communicate better with customers, suppliers, …
  20. try these out Tempe DUI lawyers - must turn that passion into something that people will seek out and want to read. this involves making your blog stand …
  21. perawatan wajah - quality of your posts.just in case you are new, blogs and forums.in essence a blog or forum simply allows someone to …
  22. minileningen - visitor finds the information they were looking for and the publisher earns a small profit.banner blindness, you've met your match. blogging …
  23. csngrdngthnfgdsfgnsfsd - Title [...]although internet sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not associated to ours, we really feel they are basically really …
  24. garcinia cambogia extract scam - have to offer. look for a blogging platform that utilises plugins. plugins are essentially software programs that enable you to add …
  25. dr oz garcinia cambogia weight loss - if you're not willing to write your own work then don't bother as your ripping someone else off but also sailing …
  26. --2557 - hurting your chances. yes, publishers have editors on staff, but they want to begin with someone who can write well and …
  27. Carpet Cleaning Machines - client you are encouraged to closely inspect your chosen copywriter's portfolio and verify any testimonials provided.at the end of the day …
  28. cirujano plastico en monterrey - accurately and ethically represents his or her knowledge, opinions and professional voice.a ghost helps lawyers select topics and venues. a professional …
  29. que son finanzas personales - for promoting business. article marketing is fast gaining prominence as one of the best ways to inform prospective customers about different …
  30. paintless dent removal training - owners can advertise without paying outrageous prices. moreover, free blogging platforms give businesses the ability to wield the sheer power of …
  31. paintless dent removal training - advertising, you should find out a particular niche. you should then create a website around that niche. in this form of …
  32. Companias de Seguros en Espana - the dialogue itself and/or the character's actions or reactions should inform the reader of the character's tone. i'm sure this is …
  33. paintless dent removal training - ask your opinion about your topic. then you will know you are a welcomed guest and will be allowed to post …
  34. muscle gaining supplement - complete sentences so that they make sense and reflect on the article you are commenting on. we are all here to …
  35. more details - your intended customers. when you make blogs for your business, make sure that you select wordpress blog templates because this platform …
  36. Urban Vista Condo Floorplan - they help you reach more customers and sales through carefully written posts for your business blogs. do you have a business …
  37. ถ่ายรูป - and get that precious traffic flowing. well, rest assured because you are reading the right article to get your brain moving …
  38. hotel discounts - - crucially - what does not work.if you would like to improve your business english, search the web for business documents …
  39. nodents.com - you. it is going to be the name of your business. but most bloggers are not blogging about their business, either …
  40. paintless dent removal training course - your part does not mean you have to settle for a template that is not suited to your likes or taste.also, …
  41. paintless dent removal training - skills can earn you good grades and offer you a lot of opportunities at school and at work. from time to …
  42. Marietta handyman - have a way or a mean to have unique world class content that people want to read, you will never have …
  43. Atlanta general contractors - "chocolate chip cookies is great" is not. some of these are obvious, some are tricky.pronoun error is another common mistake. "everybody …
  44. home remodeling Atlanta - the day progresses and you read something or meet with someone, jot down a few thoughts on that doc. if you …
  45. หาช่างภาพ.html - filled with slang terms and phrases. it seems as if instead of teaching them to improve their writing, they have to …
  46. commonwealth towers condo queenstown - of places and makes sales at the same time.why rely on just your main website to make the sale? why not …
  47. dr oz 2 week rapid weight loss meal plan - but informative and be structured so that it is easy to read. create a numbered list or a list of bullet …
  48. gxcrcfgrtgsgabdjnhacfg - Title [...]usually posts some incredibly intriguing stuff like this. If you are new to this site[...]
  49. dr oz diet plan - you can make it, and don't forget to proofread it multiple times. good luck! there is the perennial question of how …
  50. Slotomania Free Coins Ipad - not attract people to you.• if all of your posts are advertisements and selling something. that doesn't build connection. every so …
  51. http://newpropertyout.blogspot.com - with the site design? the answer to this question will help ascertain the purpose. for instance, if the link is made …
  52. visit this site - so try to include relevant images and videos for your readers and consistently look for new information to share with them.6. …
  53. check it out - topics about these systems and how a new member can master them.mlm leaders - a lot of people have climbed companies' …
  54. what is deer antler spray - that if you are not willing to learn, you are on a short, miserable, dead-end road. it doesn't matter whether you …
  55. cool site - good chance of getting these people to like you and to buy from you, all because you distilled some excellent information …
  56. check it out - be able to use widgetbox widgets.so, i did a search for a more user friendly, more accessible blog with greater functionality …
  57. garcinia cambogia diet - the good news is that they are easy to spot. you just need to read your essay, and they will gaze …
  58. get his heart - you continue to focus on higher priority aspects of your business. running a business can be a very time consuming occupation. …
  59. pure garcinia cambogia dr oz - lots of keywords. litter your post with keywords, yeah, just stuff 'em in there!" don't, seriously. search engines run algorithms that …
  60. dr oz on garcinia cambogia - content writing activities are marked for their professionalism. a trained copywriter writer understands that you need to produce fresh, updated, and …
  61. http://garciniacambogia-freetrial.net/ - and results you attained.last, form each story into a bullet-style sentence that incorporates each element, as in these examples:"increased sales 23% …
  62. testosterone booster effects - the person you are interviewing is an expert then that's just all the better.start researchingas a blogger and a writer you …
  63. http://www.krispykremecoupons.blogspot.com/ - . .
  64. insanity workout online - who you are interested in and invite them in for an interview. you can even do your interview via e-mail. if …
  65. garcinia cambogia and green coffee bean diet - can come in different designs. choose one that features brass materials as it is easier to manage and look beautiful. it …
  66. garcinia cambogia extract pure dr oz - Title [...]the time to read or visit the material or web-sites we have linked to beneath the[...]
  67. how to kill bed bugs - Title [...]here are some links to websites that we link to mainly because we assume they're worth visiting[...]
  68. My Homepage - ... [Trackback] [...] There you will find 25147 more Infos: voyageronline.com.au/fan-rage-women-the-hobbit/ [...]
  69. dr oz miracle fat burner - Title [...]Here are a number of the internet sites we suggest for our visitors[...]

Leave a Reply