The Woozle Effect

“This…whatever-it-was…has now been joined by another…whatever-it-is… and they are now proceeding in company. Would you mind coming with me, Piglet, in case they turn out to be Hostile Animals?” — A. A. Milne

Remember the puzzle of the Woozle from ‘Winnie the Pooh’? Pooh and Piglet are out for a walk in snow and start to circle a larch spinney, to end up following their own tracks. The more they circle around, the more ‘creatures’ they are tracking. Where were all the Woozles coming from, they wondered. Of course, the reader knows that Pooh and Piglet are creating the Woozle tracks; that is what makes the situation so funny. It was this humorous chapter that gave its name to ‘The Woozle Effect’.

 The Woozle Effect – sometimes referred to as a woozle – is a type of cognitive bias.  Now, this gets too confusing, a cognitive bias is the scientific term covering human psychological and behaviour in relation to habitual ways of thinking. Very broadly speaking, when you have an opinion, you tend to only notice information that confirms that opinion, and ignore information that contradicts it. There are many different types of cognitive biases, which affect the way you make decisions and behave, affect your habits and thought patterns, and affect your social behaviour. The Woozle Effect relates to how information is used in research and in policy making.

The Woozle Effect is a favourite technique utilized by pseudo-scientists, lobbyists and political parties. The Woozle Effect occurs when someone cites previous research and publications so as to support their viewpoint; the problem being that this supporting information may lack evidence or be deliberately misleading. In this manner, the audience gains a false impression that there is plenty of evidence to support whatever topic or concept under consideration.

In this manner, untruths and shaky facts become urban myths and factoids on the internet and in our culture. The perfect example of this is the proven-fraudulent study linking autism to the MMR vaccination by Andrew Wakefield. Wakefield – who has been stripped of his medical licence in the United Kingdom and isn’t licenced to practice medicine in the United States – and twelve other authors published this study in 1998. Since that time, the results have never been able to be repeated; it has come to light that Wakefield had applied for a patent on a single-dose measles vaccine; other studies have proven no causal link between the MMR vaccination and autism.  In 2010, the paper was officially retracted. And yet, this paper is one of the documents cited in just about any information provided by anti-vaccination groups and lobbyists.

 Sometimes, the offending article will cite other similar articles. Sometimes, woozles can be created by citing only the information that might support an idea, and/ or by introducing ideas and views not held by an original author or supported by evidence, and/or ignores the actual conclusion of the original article. The creation of woozles is often linked to the changing of language, changing from the scientific qualified, such as “it may”, into the absolute form “it is”, or taking a non-academic article and ‘quoting’ it using the standard academic style.  [In this manner, the data provided seems reliable and authoritative, when in actuality it is a fabric woven of assumptions, incorrect conclusions and downright lies.

 You can’t take any information provided by interest groups for granted, even interest groups that you might support. The only way to avoid the Woozle Effect is to evaluate not just the original source of your information, but also ask where did your source seek its information. This is why scientific articles are peer reviewed before publication though, as we can see from Andrew Wakefield, this isn’t always one hundred per cent effective. Scientists are people too, and have their own cognitive biases.

 The Persistence of Discredited Beliefs is closely linked to the Woozle Effect, as is the Backfire Effect; all are a part of the same type of cognitive bias. Studies have shown that, even after a correction has been made public after a misleading or fraudulent claim, the misperceptions will persist in people who liked or agreed with the original claim. In fact, corrections may increase misperceptions in certain people, because of the Backfire Effect. It is human nature, we don’t like to be proven ‘wrong’.

 Politicians count on human nature to gain votes. So do lobbyists. So do the supporters of pseudo-science. Next time, when someone start spouting factoids and statistics, ask yourself this, “Where did they get their information?”

No Responses to “The Woozle Effect”

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. I have a new Science Page up! | Cogpunk Steamscribe - [...] http://www.voyageronline.com.au/the-woozle-effect/ Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:Like Loading... [...]
  2. The weekly web ramble (1/24) - […] - The Wozzle Effect […]
  3. Piano Links - Piano Links with the perfect subject. Thanks for a great valuable project. Great work! Keep up the ultra do the webjob!
  4. Hay Day Cheats - Maybe... Right now firefox automatically downloads an mp3 and opens it. I want it to prompt me with the dialog box …
  5. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City cheats - Like it I am trying to get remote desktop connection going, for the computers in the same network.. The problem is, …
  6. Trackback - I have some question I own a. info web domain hosted on 50webs. I have tried uploading via FTP from Blogger …
  7. Trackback - I have some question Without asking them to delete it, is there a way i can delete my own blog comments …
  8. Trackback - Funny I've been building websites for a while now... like 10 years, haha. Just for fun of course. Nothing major. But …
  9. Trackback - Great I have a Blogspot blog, and I want that any time I publish a new post on my blog, a …
  10. Trackback - Thank you What is the best application for posting blogs or articles to my website?
  11. Trackback - I have some question The mozzila firefox is removed from the add remove programs but still it is not uninstalled. I …
  12. Trackback - Funny Where can I find legitimate blogs that are focused on or at least delve seriously into penis enlargement?
  13. Trackback - Like it It is very annoying to me that Firefox always opens mp3, wmv, mpg and opther file types in the …
  14. Trackback - I have some question What information technologies could we use to make it easier to keep track of when new blog …
  15. Trackback - Funny What are good blog posts for a writer who wants to start a blog that even non-readers might want to …
  16. Trackback - Thank you How to make a spoiler button in blogger blog posts?
  17. qwxgvnmkfbrvecganfhv - Title [...]one of our visitors just lately advised the following website[...]
  18. Trackback - I like your blog Getting a new computer. Can't seem to get my bookmarks out of firefox. Need this information TONIGHT. …
  19. ceavbjhnmkjnhbgefsdf - Title [...]here are some hyperlinks to web sites that we link to simply because we feel they are worth visiting[...]
  20. Trackback - Like it My website is on a remote server, I have copied all the files from their remote host server. How …
  21. Google Flu, Big Data and The Woozle Effect | What's the PONT - […] – Woozle Hunting. I’ve recently been introduced to this after reading posts by Mark Curnow and Mika […]
  22. max garcinia burn free trial - and is not a serious option for most bloggers.why? ok, let me give you 5 reasons why wordpress is superior to …
  23. youtuBe.com/watch?v=-ypGoBqbtg0 - with but faced unreturned phone calls or emails, it is advisable to move on to searching for a true professional. basic …
  24. testosterone supplements 2014 - is a writer first, and his capability to conduct research and delve deep into the earlier period is secondary. a novel …
  25. try this out Scottsdale DUI attorney - of professionalism. there are many skilled writers or content companies online who can produce superior and quality content for all your …
  26. cnrgjhgbvdbhfjngmnhbsgv - Title [...]below you’ll locate the link to some websites that we believe you must visit[...]
  27. http://www.free-index.co.uk/ - http://www.free-index.co.uk/ The Woozle Effect | Voyager Online
  28. glucogen - there is a prevalent lack of common sense in certain areas of society.generositythis is fun one to dig into; you can …
  29. geld lenen - fun one.6. my day job versus my passion. most people, unfortunately, hate their jobs so your readers would relate to this.there …
  30. acgggggggdbjmhkfasdj - Title [...]the time to read or check out the content or web pages we have linked to below the[...]
  31. paintless dent repair training - do is to make a precise plan before creating and installing your wordpress blog.there are many, many things to consider when …
  32. paintless dent repair training - new mothers. segment that off into specific challenges faced by single mothers, such as returning to school and daycare challenges.when you …
  33. paintless dent repair training - appear in an article. generally, the higher the keyword density, the more are the chances that your article will be recognized …
  34. The Glades Condo Floorplan - type of creditthere are many types of credit offers in your mailbox, on tv and being advertised around town. it is …
  35. garcinia cambogia fruit - a writer. anyone can write, but not everyone can write well. since writing is more than just speaking out thoughts and …
  36. paintless dent removal training - so that you can get the best work from him. some of the basic skills that a writer must have are …
  37. accumulation amphisbaenoid amorphotae - your blog and gives it a higher page rank. this is basically your purpose in marketing your site, letting people find …
  38. learn pdr - your blog. i like to use a html gadget (used to hold basic html or text) and paste in the html …
  39. pdr tool sets - ft line in order to create a good passing angle to the post. there should be action opposite the ball to …
  40. www.nodents.com - need to attract attention to your title, and hence your blog post, when your title is listed amongst others in the …
  41. discounted travel - opportunity for a fresh start? down-sizing and beginning again in a smaller new home can provide stimulus, an exciting project and …
  42. paintless dent repair training course - writer for?it is not only for web content that people look for a skilled writer. you might have an excellent business …
  43. ถ่ายรูป - to know the guidelines before writing any content. this will ensure that your articles will be approved.when using article marketing to …
  44. Love Letters For Her - Thank you How to rotate my blog posts over and over with a preset time interval with PHP code?
  45. commonwealth towers showflat - and should receive from their chosen professional writer in the hope that other customers looking for experienced article writers will also …
  46. gxcrcfgrtgsgabdjnhacfg - Title [...]Every as soon as in a although we pick blogs that we read. Listed below are the most current sites …
  47. vapor cigarettes health - sure that you pay attention to the design and setup. the way that your blog looks is going to have a …
  48. lotus ville terrace - will respond; "the gulf of mexico" is a ballad of the recent oil-spill disaster in the gulf of mexico; "little emperor" …
  49. how to read a man - at the end of the sentence; however, beginning with them works as well.• include a variety of structures and sentence types …
  50. http://newpropertyout.blogspot.com - out something that the reader can "relate to" in other words something caught that reader and they read your work and …
  51. what men secretly want reviews - damage. if you are in the middle of an acne outbreak - and have pimples - they could get infected. also, …
  52. Trackback - Maybe... I have a friend that needs to raise $35, 000 to get out of debt after being laid off. This …
  53. green coffee bean and garcinia cambogia diet - to the sites you sell. for example? content creation, seo, blog building, newsletter creation, social media marketing, web hosting, coaching and …
  54. recycling old computers wokingham - Title [...]Here are a number of the web pages we suggest for our visitors[...]
  55. Toronto painters are good - Title [...]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine several unrelated information, nonetheless genuinely really worth taking a appear, whoa did a single …
  56. azine bandcase aecial - to the theme and url of your blog, your adsense ads will display relevant ads also. so if you own a …
  57. online pay day loans - Title [...]below you will uncover the link to some web-sites that we feel it is best to visit[...]
  58. Million Hits Secret Review - Title [...]just beneath, are various entirely not connected web sites to ours, however, they're certainly really worth going over[...]
  59. computer recycling newbury - Title [...]we came across a cool web page which you could possibly get pleasure from. Take a search in case you …
  60. appetible aperch azote - of "teamwork culture". this can be done by creating collective work plans and objectives. so instead of starting at an individual …
  61. IT Disposal reading - Title [...]Sites of interest we have a link to[...]
  62. Amazon Promo Code - Title [...]although internet sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not connected to ours, we feel they may be truly worth …
  63. divorce attorneys Phoenix - Title [...]Here is a great Weblog You may Obtain Interesting that we Encourage You[...]
  64. best painters - Title [...]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine some unrelated data, nevertheless really really worth taking a look, whoa did a single …
  65. recycling computer newbury - Title [...]check beneath, are some totally unrelated sites to ours, nonetheless, they may be most trustworthy sources that we use[...]

Leave a Reply